Thank you for the FAQ, very useful!
1 Like
I agree with your proposal, since they have since sold their NFT, it might indicate they are no longer interested and to add to that since $CODE will be available on the market, they can simply buy some $CODE back if they are interested.
I donāt think itās such a harsh proposal, especially if you consider someone can, sell their NFT the day after the snapshot, then promptly sell their 400 $CODE as well, thus selling out not once but twice.
3 Likes
I do see my address there, but not eligible for the POAP bonus because I minted it just before it ran out, didnāt get a chance to vote.
Yeah in the same boat.
I strongly agree with the functional mission and distribution of governance tokens and expect code to make DevDAO more powerful
1 Like
I like this activity very much. I hope Iām lucky. Thank you very much!
Hello, may I ask, can new members who come in later can only purchase tokens from the secondary market to obtain membership?
Defining contributions on this granular-a-level is super difficult. My personal feelings are any action in the community is a contribution but that is very hard to track. Using Coordinape has been suggested as it allows for a bottom-up (rather than top-down) approach to rewards so hopefully even those who havenāt had the chance to contribute to a project in a trackable way (like a commit) can still potentially receive Early Contributors rewards from others in the community they have helped in others ways.
Best way to understand how Coordinape works is to view a video, this ones quite good - Coordinape - Decentralize Payroll for the Modern DAO - YouTube
3 Likes
I agree with you and thatās also why I was asking 
I got a quick question for this, so I joined the developer dao in a very initial phase, and in the discord, I suggested opening help specific channel, to encourage the developer help each other .So, it was just an idea that I proposed and then the mods acted on this idea, so can this be considered as the contribution from my side to the DAO,?
Yes as I said I think any action in the community is a contribution. That doesnāt necessarily mean that every individual action can or should be tracked and rewarded. We felt taking a bottom up approach using Coordinape for Early Contributions was on balance fairer and more feasible than a top down approach that tries to explicitly track and reward every action taken retrospectively.
1 Like
Wasnāt gitcoin supposed to get 5% of the supply?
Iām a bit confused that it states 11.1% in the FAQ and 5% in the proposal.
Gitcoin is still proposed to receive 5%. That 11.1% reflects active governing power at the time the token is issued, not the supply. That governing power is a larger, because the 50% in the treasury isnāt eligible to vote and founder/advisor tokens are subject to vesting.
3 Likes
I like the idea of checking two snapshots.
I have another case. I actually own two NFTs and thought about giving away one (to interested people on twitter). But as far as I understand how things are planned now the receiving person wouldnāt actually have any benefit from this, right?
1 Like
agree with this too, the NFT should be the key of the chest. Maybe you can design it to burn the NFT to get the airdropped token
1 Like
Just my opinion but this seems fair to me to only allow current 721 holders receive $CODE tokens and not drop $CODE to wallets that have sold, traded, burned the 721 agter the snapshot.
To me this is a good counterbalance to not dropping tokens to people that acquired the 721 after the snapshot.
For example, I minted two 721s and gave one to my friend as a way to get him involved. I am only eligible for one airdrop and he is not eligible for any.
I think that if we drop $CODE to people holding no 721s, we should also issue $CODE to wallets that currently hold a 721 but didnāt at the snapshot.
I hope that made sense. It kind of felt like I was.typing in circles trying to articulate that.
1 Like
Why not have diminishing returns for early voters? Can early contributors also be based off early discord participation? A lot of us were contributing a lot of ideas early on
Letās put up a vote!
Whoever sold NFT before airdrop, should be excluded from the $CODE airdrop.
1 Like